46  / SEEDWORLD.COM  DECEMBER 2026
What Happens When Trade Policy Overlooks Seed?
We asked the American 
Seed Trade Association’s 
(ASTA) vice president of sci­
ence, trade and global affairs, 
Sam Crowell, where the 
biggest trade headaches are 
coming from and what it will 
take to address them. 
Seed World: ASTA spent 
much of this year fighting 
tariffs on seed. What did 
that fight expose about how 
vulnerable the U.S. seed 
industry’s R&D model is to 
trade policy? 
Sam Crowell: The develop­
ments over the past 18-24 
months have reiterated how 
important it is for the seed 
sector to communicate the 
reality of our business: inter­
national seed movement is 
an essential part of how our 
industry delivers innovation 
to U.S. farmers. After work­
ing with our colleagues in 
the U.S. government over 
many months, ASTA was 
successful in these efforts. 
Since July, we have secured 
tariff exemptions for most 
categories of imported plant­
ing seeds coming from the 
majority of global markets.  
Moving forward, it will be 
critical for our industry to 
continue to rally government 
officials to align on trade and 
regulatory policies, and we in­
vite everyone to get more in­
volved with ASTA as we chart 
the future of our advocacy. 
SW: ASTA says it pre­
vented new phytosanitary 
requirements this year that 
could have affected more 
than $45 million in annual 
seed exports. Where are you 
seeing the biggest discon­
nect between phytosanitary 
requirements and the actual 
risk associated with seed? 
SC: My colleague, Dr. 
Martha Malapi, gets major 
kudos on this topic; she’s re­
sponsible for leading ASTA’s 
engagement across a wide 
range of phytosanitary issues 
impacting the seed business. 
In practical terms, she and 
ASTA members have the 
never-ending job of working 
to protect millions of dollars 
in trade – every time govern­
ment officials move to update 
the phytosanitary procedures 
that control seed movement. 
In some cases, changes to 
phyto procedures are war­
ranted. New pests or diseases 
emerge that require controls 
in order to prevent spread of 
a pest in the field. However, in 
other cases, draft regulatory 
measures can accidentally 
miss the mark. For example, 
we see a lot of proposed 
regulations that attempt to 
control pests or diseases 
that are not actually seed 
borne (i.e., they cannot even 
be transmitted by a seed). 
In other cases, proposed 
changes cannot feasibly be 
implemented because seed 
health tests don’t even exist 
yet, or policies go into effect 
without appropriate transi­
tion times for companies to 
respond and produce seed in 
compliance with new require­
ments. In the most frustrating 
examples, changes to certifi­
cate requirements that have 
nothing to do with safety lead 
to stuck shipments, due to 
confusion between regula­
tory and customs officials at a 
port of entry. 
Looking to the future, I 
think our biggest challenge is 
our industry’s diversity. The 
size of individual crop spe­
cies or markets impacted by 
regulatory measures can in 
fact be quite small – when 
compared to other agricultur­
al industries. In market terms, 
you can sympathize with a 
government official who is 
worried about a hypotheti­
cal pest and makes a stra­
tegic trade-off; a protective 
phytosanitary measure seems 
worthwhile when compared 
to the loss of a $300K-$3M 
in imports, which could be 
viewed as barely a rounding 
error. However, the long-term 
ramifications for the future of 
agriculture are significant. It 
is critical for governments to 
work together to implement 
science-based policies. 
SW: Seed companies tend 
to think about market access 
crop by crop and country 
by country. When you look 
across all of them, what pat­
terns do you see? 
SC: It’s hard to generalize 
with such a diverse industry, 
because different buckets of 
the sector tend to operate in 
different ways. For example, 
there are unique challenges 
facing the turf grass indus­
try’s exports of large, con­
tainerized seed shipments, vs. 
the veg and flower industry’s 
need for smaller R&D re­
search plots across a wide 
range of countries, vs. the 
row crop industry’s historical 
challenges with regulatory 
barriers to innovative tech­
nologies. 
This is why ASTA’s over­
arching trade advocacy 
focuses as much as possible 
on addressing the root cause 
of barriers that exist for the 
whole industry. Our big buck­
et priorities have always been 
to align intellectual property 
(IP) approaches, biotechnol­
ogy regulations, and phytos­
anitary regulations — and we 
work hard to promote best 
practices and engage regula­
tors with practical solutions. 
As new issues like tariffs have 
become more urgent, we’ve 
pivoted accordingly.  SW

View this content as a flipbook by clicking here.